CaraCara Mexican Grill

354 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, United States
+1 516-777-2272
$$$ Mexican restaurant , Bar , Latin American restaurant , Restaurant
(894 Reviews)
Price Range $30–50

CaraCara Mexican Grill at 354 Main St in Farmingdale offers a full-service dining experience centered on Mexican and Latin American flavors with a modern, lively twist. Walking in, you’ll notice a spacious layout that balances a bustling bar area near the entrance—with high chairs and cozy booths—with a more relaxed main dining room toward the back, decorated with vibrant Frida Kahlo-inspired artwork that keeps the atmosphere visually engaging without feeling overdone.

The vibe here works well for a casual dinner with friends or a low-key date night, especially if you’re into good conversations paired with well-made cocktails. The bar is a social spot in its own right, with a decent tequila selection and popular drinks like Margaritas on the Rocks and house-made Sangría enhancing the experience. The indoor seating is roomy, and there are a few tables outside for milder evenings, making it flexible for different moods and seasons.

On the food front, CaraCara leans on authentic Mexican staples executed with attention to detail and quality. The guacamole, served tableside, draws a crowd—not just for its freshness but for the sizable portions that can easily be shared or saved for later. Appetizers like the Calamares y Chorizo stand out for their mix of tender fried calamari and spicy chorizo, a mix of textures and flavors that shows thoughtful preparation. For mains, shrimp and fish tacos are consistent favorites, while heartier options like Dos Carnes and the perfectly balanced Carne Asada highlight a menu that caters both to those looking for casual bites and more filling plates.

This spot is well-suited for local diners who appreciate Mexican food beyond the basics. It’s the kind of place where you can settle in for the evening, savor some well-mixed margaritas and sangría, and try a variety of dishes from shareable nachos to more complex entrees like their short ribs or Quesadilla Birria served with braised beef and Guajillo broth.

Expect attentive but unobtrusive service, with a friendly staff that supports a relaxed yet vibrant dining environment. The mix of lively bar energy and quieter dining space means you can enjoy different dining moods, whether it’s a lively weekend night or a weekday dinner. The décor and menu reflect a respect for Mexican tradition with enough modern touches to feel fresh and approachable—perfect for locals looking to explore Latin American flavors without leaving Farmingdale.

Highlights
Has fast service
Has great beer selection
Serves great cocktails
Serves great dessert
Has great wine list
Good for watching sport
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
What they serve
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Serves cocktails
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves food
Serves happy-hour drinks
Serves happy-hour food
Serves healthy options
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves spirits
Serves vegetarian dishes
Serves wine
Best for
Serves brunch
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Plenty of parking

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

12:00 PM - 08:45 PM

Tuesday

12:00 PM - 08:45 PM

Wednesday

12:00 PM - 08:45 PM

Thursday

12:00 PM - 08:45 PM

Friday

12:00 PM - 09:45 PM

Saturday

12:00 PM - 09:45 PM

Sunday

12:00 PM - 08:30 PM

894 Reviews
Janice

09 Jan 2026

*UPDATE* below review At the suggestion of my step sons Spanish teacher (thank you Ms Whitney) we went to CaraCara for dinner, just happened to be St Patricks day. We ordered 2 appetizers, the calamari y chorizo, delish, perfectly cooked and tender, we also order the pollo tamales, I'm not a mole fan so had them remove it. I want you to know, this is no ordinary tamale, I would call it deconstructed, the corn masa was the consistency of polenta rather than the dense consistency one normally thinks of for tamles with a hint of sweetness. The chicken was marinated and cooked to perfection, shredded atop the corn masa sprinkled with cheese and fresh cilantro. I've eaten tamales from Arizona to New York and these are my absolute favorite. Chef's kiss to the creator of this menu item! For our main coarse we ordered carne tampiquena and dos carnes. My stepson had the carne tampiquena, cooked well done. The skirt steak was tender, juicy and full of flavor, additionally the portion serving of steak was more than adequate. I had the dos carnes, the short rib was full of flavor, fork tender and simply delicious. Unfortuneately my rib had a large portion of fat on the inside that was about 40% of the size of the rib, the skirt steak was medium rare and again delicious, however, with this dish I feel the portion size was a little lacking. They serve the rice and beans "family style" in what I would guess are 1 1/2 cup crocks, it was plenty for us but if the rest of my family were there, it wouldn't have been enough. I didn't have any drinks this night but the drink menu looks wonderful. Overall, I love this place and will surely be back to try other menu items and of course my new favorite. UPDATE: I enjoyed the Pollo tamale so much I went back 2 days later and ordered one to go. While the portion size for dine-in was enough for both my step son and I, sadly the take out version did not live up to my expectations. It looked rushed in its construction, missing the cheese and barely any of that wonderful corn masa I enjoyed so much previously.

Sayaka S

11 Dec 2025

Very nice Mexican restaurant with great food and drink. Their tequila selection is pretty wide and well. Service was very friendly and attentive as well. The table side guacamole is a must-have. The potion was so big that I ended up taking half of it home. They have spacious indoor dining area and also few outside seating as well.

K D

15 Nov 2025

REALLY nice night! Suggested by a friend & we were not disappointed ! Fabulous menu, WE’D GO BACK JUST FOR THE NACHOS! Small plates, large plates, wine, beer, our shrimp was perfect! NEVER BEEN THERE? ,YA GOTTA GO! You won’t be disappointed!

Juan Lima

06 Oct 2025

A very large restaurant with an inviting bar scene with high chairs and booths upon entry. The main dining hall is towards the back of the restaurant, and you'll see Frida Kahlo inspired portraits throughout. Ordered a couple of drinks, Calamari, and Chorizo as the appetizer, Carne Asada and Dos Carne for the main courses. The calamari was great. The skirt steak was a bit chewy by nature, but the best part was the short ribs, which was tear off the bone tender, juicy, and delicous.

Join the CaraCara Mexican Grill Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.